This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

Over the summer, a Bronx father named Horacio was handed a pamphlet outside a subway station. It advertised a new elementary school open from 7 a.m. to 7 p.m., seven days a week, 12 months a year.

Strive Charter School opened in August, and Lauren Hilgers spent months reporting on it for New York Magazine. Classes run from 9 to 4:30 on weekdays. Early mornings, evenings, weekends and summer are optional and free. Founder Eric Grannis built the school around working parents’ schedules. One father, a security guard whose daughter’s last school filled its after-school program by lottery, told Hilgers, “I need some certainty.”

I grew up hearing that summer vacation exists because kids were needed on the farm. So did a lot of people. A 2014 PBS NewsHour piece found Time, NPR and then-Education Secretary Arne Duncan all repeating it.

Historian Kenneth Gold of the College of Staten Island, cited by both PBS and Hilgers, explains that farm children were needed for spring planting and fall harvest. Rural schools often met in summer. City schools, meanwhile, were open nearly all year. Boston’s ran 244 days in 1841, according to a history by James Pedersen of Seton Hall.

The long summer break took hold in the second half of the 19th century. Wealthier families were leaving hot cities, attendance fell, and reformers wanted a common calendar for urban and rural schools. By 1900, Pedersen writes, the 180-day year was standard. Gold told PBS that none of the reasons had to do with student achievement.

Educators have been questioning inherited schedules for decades. In a 1961 issue of ASCD’s Educational Leadership, Stanford’s Robert Bush asked why high schools could not vary the length of a class period. “The main obstacle is a traditional way of doing things,” he wrote.

Bush was asking how schools could organize time around learning. Strive adds the question of how they organize it around families’ lives. For parents, the hours outside class still have to be covered: before work, after dismissal, over the summer. A school schedule becomes a work schedule, too.

Hilgers is careful about what Strive has demonstrated so far. The United Federation of Teachers is suing over the license transfer from Success Academy that created the school, arguing it violates the city’s charter cap. Grannis expects a judge to dismiss the case. Teachers work 210 days a year, compared with 180 in district schools, and experienced teachers earn well below the district scale. One mother Hilgers followed moved her daughter elsewhere by the end of October.

The finances also depend on growth. Weekend hours cost about $250,000 a year, which Grannis says the budget can cover at 325 students. The school has about 200.

On Strive’s first Saturday, just over 40 students came through the doors. The last one left at 7 p.m., after dinner.

— Thomas

K-12 Education

Higher Education

Federal Policy & Politics

2026 Elections

Early Learning & Child Care

State & Local News

Educator Talent & Staffing

AI & Technology

Student Health, Safety & Nutrition

Workforce & Career Pathways

School Choice

Job Opportunities

Looking for your next opportunity in education? W/A Jobs features 3,100+ career opportunities from 300+ organizations across the education industry.

Recommended for you

View all
caret-right