This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

Most parents have never seen a list of the software their child’s school uses. New guidelines from Stand for Children say every district should publish one: each tool, what it is for, and which grades use it.

The guide, developed with Digital Promise, SETDA and CASEL, covers how districts choose, monitor and review classroom technology and school-issued devices. Its final section is about what families are told. Districts should make their technology policies public, send parents usage reports for the programs their children use, publish regular summaries of what the data shows and report to the school board every year. Approved tools get reviewed at least every two years, with parent feedback as part of the review.

That’s the section I’d start with. In July, Michael Petrilli asked readers about Los Angeles Unified’s screen time limits, and I wrote that districts had brought some of the backlash against classroom technology on themselves. Districts rushed devices out during Covid, skipped the teacher training and left students on low-value apps for years. When parents can’t see what happens inside the building, “the worst example fills the vacuum.” A district that asks for trust has to show which tools are producing learning, which are wasting time and what it is fixing. Parents are more reasonable than the politics suggest when someone levels with them.

The politics have moved quickly. Four states passed laws this year limiting technology in the classroom, Digital Promise CEO Jean-Claude Brizard writes in the guide’s foreword, and most treat all screen time the same. Supporters have a case. Petrilli’s colleague David Griffith wrote that after a decade of falling achievement, the burden of proof belongs to tech companies. ISTE CEO Richard Culatta argued in The 74 that a cap on minutes treats a math tutoring app and TikTok alike. Brizard’s version: “Screen time asks how long. Screen value asks what for.” The guide sets nine criteria a tool must meet before a district approves it, including evidence of improved student outcomes.

A national survey published this month by InnovateEDU gives each side something. Three in four pre-K-5 parents and educators said schools should focus on whether technology improves learning, ahead of how many minutes students spend on screens. They also want it used sparingly in those grades: the most common choice in every group was a classroom that is 10% technology and 90% print or hands-on work.

On phones, the evidence is arriving. A Harvard-led study released Tuesday followed 3.3 million students and found that schools locking phones in pouches for the day added the equivalent of one to two weeks of learning a year. (There is also an app-based alternative that blocks social media and games during the school day while the phone stays with the student.) The study has not yet been peer reviewed. Stanford’s Tom Dee, whose earlier, peer-reviewed study of the same pouches found close to zero effect, told NPR the early research is “largely disappointing.” Stand’s guide treats the two policies as complements: a bell-to-bell phone ban, plus filtering on the devices the school hands out.

The transparency point reaches past technology. Chalkbeat’s Lily Altavena reports today on districts presenting school closures in upbeat language. Tucson’s plan is titled Reimagining Our Schools Together. Consultants who help write these plans told Altavena the optimism is sincere: closing under-enrolled buildings frees money for the schools that remain. One of them, Lisa Relou, added a caution that districts should not promise more than they can deliver. Tucson parent Alexis Cervantes, whose second grader attends a school proposed for closure, hears the language as a label applied to make the plan look better. In Aurora, Colorado, the district spent years collecting feedback on a plan called Blueprint APS before parents learned it included closing schools. “I wish they would have explained everything from the beginning,” parent Brenda Pineda said in 2022.

— Thomas

K-12 Education

Higher Education

Federal Policy & Politics

Early Learning & Child Care

State & Local News

Educator Talent & Staffing

AI & Technology

Workforce & Career Pathways

School Choice

Job Opportunities

Looking for your next opportunity in education? W/A Jobs features 3,100+ career opportunities from 300+ organizations across the education industry.

Recommended for you

View all
caret-right