This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

Editor’s note: Thursday’s edition is arriving this morning because of the Microsoft Outlook outage, which held up delivery last night. We’re back to our regular evening schedule on Monday.

The New Yorker’s Jessica Winter published a sweeping critique today of the private capital behind New York City’s curricula and edtech. Her argument: investors have financialized public schools, and students are paying the price.

Some of it lands. Gamified reward loops with no evidence behind them deserve scrutiny. So do vendors that measure their products with their own tests.

But “technofeudalism” is a lot to ask of a parent trying to figure out whether the reading program works. Winter’s list runs from Blooket, a quiz game her daughter plays in social studies, to the reading assessments the city gives three times a year. One hands out cartoon avatars. The other is intended to identify students who need reading support. Those tools deserve scrutiny on different terms. She treats both as symptoms of the same problem.

The reading data carries much of the weight. Winter ties a nine-point NAEP decline in New York to tests crowding out books. But the decline needs a longer timeline. National scores peaked around 2013 and have fallen since, a slide federal officials said in June began well before the pandemic. The city’s assessment mandate dates to 2021 and its curriculum mandate to 2023. Those policies cannot explain the full decline.

National results offer some encouraging context. Nine-year-olds gained in reading on the long-term trend NAEP released in June, and the lowest performers gained the most. Those results measure a different population and assessment from New York’s fourth grade scores. NAEP can’t show cause, and one governing board member warned against reading a trend into a single result. Kymyona Burk, who ran Mississippi’s early reading law as state literacy director, offered an explanation: “What gets measured gets done.” Mississippi, where I grew up, raised its fourth grade scores with structured literacy instruction, universal screening and coaching. That approach relies on the kind of standardized materials and testing Winter wants to pull back.

The piece ends with a parent leader hoping classrooms return to textbooks and Scantrons, two things Winter remembers from her own schooling in the 1980s and ’90s. A Scantron is a bubble sheet for machine-scored multiple-choice tests, the same format one of her sources blames for students who lack the stamina to finish a book. The textbooks came from private publishers then too, as Winter acknowledges. HMH, one of the vendors she criticizes, dates to the early 1800s.

The backlash she describes is real, and it is already shaping policy in the country’s largest district. Her case would be stronger if it sorted the tools failing kids from the ones that work. The evidence for doing that is thin. In Education Next, Morgan Polikoff and Jake Scollan-Rowley report that a review of 36 studies of K-5 English curricula turned up only a handful they could trust. They put the blame on states, which never tracked which curricula schools adopt and left publishers to pay for their own studies.

Two attempts at sorting arrived this week. Harvard’s education school released a tool that rates AI uses by a child’s age and the skill being built, drawing on more than 5,000 pieces of research. And today the Center for Outcomes Based Contracting rolled out a designation for tutoring and edtech providers. A qualifying contract ties at least 40% of its value to student outcomes. The top tier goes only to providers that hit at least half of those outcomes, using data the district validates. The top two tiers attach to individual contracts, not to the company. That is a direct answer to companies grading their own work. Since 2021, 87 education agencies in 26 states have worked with the Center on these contracts.

— Thomas

K-12 Education

Higher Education

Federal Policy & Politics

Early Learning & Child Care

State & Local News

Educator Talent & Staffing

AI & Technology

Student Health, Safety & Nutrition

Workforce & Career Pathways

School Choice

Also Reading

Job Opportunities

Looking for your next opportunity in education? W/A Jobs features 3,100+ career opportunities from 300+ organizations across the education industry.

Recommended for you

View all
caret-right